Thursday, November 15, 2007

Unreliable-Outdated Panel Probe Report – No Update Additional 10Sec? Report Submitted on 6th, Anwar Revealed on 8th Nov; Futile Cabinet Decision?

Malaysiakini has the latest report on the Lingam Video Clip controversy under

Lingam tape: Cabinet yet to decide, says Nazri

= = == = == = == = ==UPDATE: -

Thursday November 15, 2007; MYT 2:25:59 PM; STAR
Video clip probe: Cabinet ministers will not meet
KUALA LUMPUR: The three senior Cabinet ministers appointed to study the panel report on the video clip purportedly featuring a senior lawyer brokering the appointment of top judges will not be meeting. One of the ministers, Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Seri Nazri Abd Aziz, said the three would be presenting their opinion and recommendations to the Cabinet next Wednesday after reading the report. "We will give our individual input,'' he said.

The other two ministers are Home Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Radzi Sheikh Ahmad and Culture, Arts and Heritage Minister Datuk Seri Dr Rais Yatim. "The Cabinet also needs the input of other ministers just in case we miss some points. "It is better to have 32 heads than only three heads,'' said Nazri, adding that the Cabinet was serious about the whole incident and wanted to investigate further.

[…]= == = == = ==

UPDATE:
the NST has the inside info as with Sin Chew?
The STAR no longer privy to leaks?

Panel favours a royal commission
By : Anis Ibrahim and V. Vasudevan
KUALA LUMPUR: The panel examining the authenticity of the "Lingam" video clip may have sent separate reports, but there was a common thread - all members agreed that the matter should be investigated by a royal commission of inquiry. The New Straits Times learnt yesterday that the panel had concluded that the video clip featuring senior lawyer V.K. Lingam was authentic and that the issue warranted further investigation. The proposal is likely to be lauded by the Malaysian Bar, which recommended that a royal commission be set up to investigate the clip. The clip allegedly showed Lingam brokering judicial appointments with a senior member of the judiciary. The final decision on the panel's findings will be decided by the cabinet next week.

The three-member panel submitted three individual reports of the video clip to the government on Friday. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Seri Nazri Aziz said the cabinet was given a brief of the findings by the Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Sidek Hasan. "We will be able to give you a decision next week. All the ministers will be given a copy of the report today," he said. Nazri said while all cabinet members would be asked for their input next week, three cabinet members with legal background would give a legal perspective.

Nazri said apart from himself, the other two are Home Affairs Minister Datuk Seri Radzi Sheikh Ahmad and Culture, Arts and Heritage Minister Datuk Seri Utama Dr Rais Yatim. Pressed repeatedly as to what the recommendation by the panel was, Nazri kept saying he did not know. "I have yet to read it. Wait till next week." When told that Sin Chew Daily had reported that the panel had recommended a Royal Commission of Inquiry be set up, Nazri said that was the paper's view.

Earlier, in a statement based on the Sin Chew report, opposition leader Lim Kit Siang said if the report was true then Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi had to establish the commission. Lim said the question then would be the terms of reference and composition of the Royal Commission of Inquiry. "In such circumstances, the prime minister should undertake a proper and meaningful consultation with representative personalities and groups.

"This is to ensure that the Royal Commission of Inquiry, when established, would not become another divisive issue, either because of its restricted terms of reference, controversial composition or procrastination," he said. The panel, formed in September, was headed by former chief judge of Malaya Tan Sri Haidar Mohd Noor and made up of former Court of Appeal judge Datuk Mahadev Shankar and social activist Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye.

= == = =Original Post below
Is the cabinet getting any updated report from the Panel? It seems not to be the case.
ABOVE: Haider came with his bag and BELOW: Left empty handed. Did he submit the report together with the bag or absent-mindedly left it behind?

On Nov 6, the panel members handed their individual reports, bound into one, to the secretariat – the Prime Minister’s Department’s legal division. PKR claimed the original recording was 14 minutes long and had withheld a footage of six minutes to protect the identity of the sources.

Last Thursday (Nov 8), Anwar (ABOVE with his thumb drive)released an additional 10-second clip from the withheld portion, in which Lingam was depicted telling somebody that his conversation was with the recently-retired Chief Justice Tun Ahmad Fairuz Sheikh Abdul Halim. Najib said on the same day, the Panel “will have to look at that” but there were NO further meetings. So the report at hand with the cabinet is INCOMPLETE and any decision on it would be futile, if the additional 10 sec was not taken into consideration.

And the reliability of the Report is at stake if the panel members based their findings on authenticity from the Cyber Security firms. It was revealed on Day 57 Altantuya Murder (details H E R E), the Cyber Security firm witness (Mohd Zabri Aidil Talib, 28) (BELOW)

when questioned by Hazman Ahmad, counsel for C/Insp Azilah Hadri said ”he was neither gazetted to testify as an expert nor was the agency accredited by any independent body” And this private company funded by the Government had presented a report to the Panel “that there is a possibility the Lingam Clip is not authentic” –details in previous post H E RE
So are they qualified to assess and verify the Lingam Video Clip and can they be considered “independent” and reliable?
= = == = == = == = == = == = == = =

November 14, 2007 21:37 PM
Cabinet To Make Decision On Video Clip Probe Next Week

KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 14 (Bernama) -- The Cabinet will decide on the follow up action regarding the investigation into a video clip showing a lawyer attempting to influence a judge on the appointment of judges, next week. Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Seri Mohd Nazri (ABOVE)Abdul Aziz said the Cabinet ministers would be provided with copies of the probe report tomorrow. "We will announce the decision next week," he told reporters when met at Parliament's lobby today.

The Cabinet was briefed on the probe into the case by the Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Mohd Sidek (ABOVE) Hassan yesterday, he said. Nazri said that three ministers with law backgrounds including himself were tasked to make suggestions on the follow up action needed. The other two are Home Affairs Minister Datuk Seri Radzi Sheikh Ahmad and Culture, Arts and Heritage Minister, Datuk Seri Dr Rais Yatim. On a report in a Chinese newspaper which said that the special independent panel tasked with verifying the authenticity of the clip had suggested that a Royal Commission of Inquiry be set up over the case, Nazri said it was "only a report in a newspaper".

= == = =
Wednesday November 14, 2007;MYT 8:39:09 PM

Three named to study videoclip report
By ELIZABETH LOOI and LEE YUK PENG; STAR
KUALA LUMPUR: Three senior ministers have been appointed to study the three-man panel's report on the videoclip that showed a lawyer brokering judges’ appointments in a phone conversation. The three, appointed by the Prime Minister, are Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Seri Nazri Aziz, Home Minister Datuk Seri Mohd Radzi Sheikh Ahmad and Culture, Arts and Heritage Minister Datuk Seri Dr Rais Yatim. Nazri said they were given the task by the Cabinet due to their legal background and also because all three had been in charge of law affairs in their ministerial portfolios. They would recommend the appropriate action to be taken at the next Cabinet meeting next Wednesday. The Cabinet had also decided that each minister be given a copy of the report. Nazri also said the three-man panel had submitted the report to the Chief Secretary, who in turn briefed the Cabinet on Wednesday.
“I can only tell you that the Cabinet was briefed but I can’t tell you what we were briefed on,” he said. On talk that the panel had recommended the setting up of a Royal Commission of Inquiry, Nazri said he would have to read the report first. The panel, comprising former Chief Judge of Malaya Tan Sri Haidar Mohd Noor, social activist Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye and former Court of Appeal judge Datuk Mahadev Shankar, was formed on Sept 25 to investigate the authenticity of the videoclip. It completed its report on Nov 6.

= = == = =and talk only, no discussion, can ONLY flip thru report
November 13, 2007 21:24 PM
Cabinet To Discuss "Lingam" Video Clip Report Wednesday
KUCHING, Nov 13 (Bernama) -- The report by a special independent panel set up to verify the authenticity of the "Lingam" video clip will be discussed at the Cabinet meeting Wednesday, said Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi. "We hope to be able to discuss it Wednesday when the report is presented before the Cabinet," he told reporters after laying the foundation stone for the Sarawak Islamic Complex (KIS) here Tuesday. The video clip purportedly shows a prominent lawyer on the phone with a senior judge discussing judicial appointments. Asked about its content, Abdullah admitted that he did not have time to read the report.

"I will go through the report tonight," he added in Kuching.Where he got time? Flip thru maybe & fell asleep!

The report was prepared by the panel's members comprising of former chief judge of Malaya Tan Sri Haidar Mohd Noor, social activist Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye and former court of appeals judge Datuk Mahadev Shankar. It was formed on Sept 25 to investigate the authenticity of the video clip. The panel completed its report on Nov 6.
[...]
= == = == = =

November 13, 2007 12:15 PM
Government To Assess Panel's Report In A Matter Of Days - Najib

KUALA LUMPUR, Nov 13 (Bernama) -- The Government will assess in a matter of days the report submitted by the special independent panel formed to determine the authenticity of a video clip showing a senior lawyer purportedly brokering the appointment of judges, Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak said Tuesday.
The Deputy Prime Minister said: "Yes (we have received it). I don't have time to look at the report yet (but) I would assess the report in a matter of days and I would discuss with the PM (Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi) on what to do."
"We realise there is a great public interest to make the report public," he told reporters after opening the 10th Asia-Pacific Responsible Care Conference (APRCC 2007) and 35th Asean Chemical Industries Council Conference (ACIC).


Najib was asked whether the government would make public the contents of the report after the three-man panel comprising former Chief Judge of Malaya Tan Sri Haidar Mohd Noor (ABOVE),

National Service Council chairman Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye (ABOVE, leaving after giving report) and former Court of Appeal judge Datuk Mahadev Shankar (BELOW) handed their reports to the government last week.

The panel was set up on September 25 to hold a full inquiry, analyse the evidence and make a decision on the authenticity of the video clip taken in 2002.
In announcing the formation of the panel, Najib had said the panel's findings would be "the key" and "the government will take it from there".

= = == = = = Coming next post, Forum Discussion on the Bersih Rally

8 min 46s or less Video Clip, possible Transcript


0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home

Get complete protection against viruses, worms and Trojan horse programs – CA Anti-Virus 2008! Click here for cheap hotels
www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from Multidimid. Make your own badge here.
Blogroll Me!

Your email address:


Powered by FeedBlitz

Add to Google Add to Google
Google
 
Web powerpresent.blogspot.com