MORE PICS – New Habeas Corpus filed in KL - ISA Detainees M Manoharan & V Ganabatirau by Karpal Singh after Rejection earlier in IPOH on Technicality
Two Hindraf leaders file habeas corpus applications
They named the Internal Security Minister and the Kamunting Detention Centre’s superintendent as respondents In the affidavit, P. Waytha Nayagi, who affirmed the document to support the application for her brother Uthayakumar, said his arrest in Bangsar last Thursday and continued detention was unconstitutional and unlawful. Waytha Nayagi, 41, said there had been contravention of the provisions of the Federal Constitution and non-compliance with the provisions of rules of Internal Security (Advisory Board Procedure) Rules 1972. She said the allegations against her brother were groundless and asked the court to declare the detention order null and void. She applied for him to be brought to the court and released forthwith. In a notice of motion Waytha Nayagi also asked for any order deemed fit by the court.
In the other habeas corpus application, K. Vickneswary, wife of Vasantha Kumar, affirmed an affidavit for the purpose. Vickneswary, 35, said her husband's arrest in Brickfields last Thursday was not in accordance with law and illegal. She said the minister had acted mechanically and prematurely and that the allegations of fact against her husband were baseless and that his continued detention was unconstitutional and unlawful. She applied for him to be brought to the court and be set at free as well as any further order deemed proper by the court.
Speaking to reporters later, Karpal Singh said: "We are serving the papers of four applicants (lawyers M. Manoharan, V. Ganabatirau, Uthayakumar and former senior executive Vasantha Kumar) to the minister so that they will be ready for the hearing at High Court on Wednesday before Judicial Commissioner Zainal Azman Abdul Aziz," he added.= = == = == = = =Original Post Below
Malaysiakini has the early report on the application being rejected in IPOH and an evening update
MORE PICS – New Habeas Corpus filed in KL - ISA Detainees M. Manoharan & V. Ganabatirau by Karpal Singh after Rejection earlier in
Apparently thecopy of the Detention order was uncertified. A fresh application is being submitted today late afternoon in KL.
Habeas corpus is a writ ordering prisoners to be brought before a court or judge to ascertain if there are any procedural defects which could render their detention unlawful
Karpal Files Fresh Habeas Corpus Application
The application for a writ of habeas corpus was filed by lawyer Karpal Singh (ABOVE) of Messrs Karpal Singh and Co at the High Court registry at about . Karpal Singh also filed a similar application to free another ISA detainee, V. Ganabatirau. He filed the applications on behalf of Manoharan's wife, P. Pushpaneela, 48 and Ganabathirau's younger brother, V. Papparaidu, 33. They named the Internal Security Minister as first respondent and the
Taiping Detention Camp Superitendent as the second respondent. In their affidavits they claimed that the detentions were unconstitutional and not in accordance with the law. They also stated that the purported grounds of detention were groundless and are seeking a court order to declare the arrests illegal and unlawful and the detention orders, null and void. Together with the applications, Karpal filed a certificate of urgency for the matter to be heard as soon as possible. The court will hear their applications on Dec 26. Earlier today in
= == = = =from Star
Hindraf lawyer files new habeas corpus application
By M. MAGESWARI;
Pushpaneela who affirmed an affidavit to support the application, said her husband's arrest last Thursday and continued detention was unconstitutional and unlawful. She is seeking for an order from the court to release him forthwith on grounds that his detention was unlawful. At the same time, Karpal Singh also filed a similar application at the High Court (criminal) registry for lawyer V. Ganabatirau. V. Papparaidu, 32, who is Ganabatirau's brother, affirmed an affidavit in support of the application. Papparaidu who adopted similar points as Manoharan, is seeking for an order from the court for his release forthwith. The two-year detention order, effective from last Thursday, had stated that Manoharan and Ganabatirau had played an active part in the unregistered Hindu Rights Action Force (Hindraf) activities since October this year. The two were said to have acted as its leaders and legal advisors where Hindraf was said to have organise activities that could threaten the security of the country. High Court Judicial Commissioner Zainal Azman Abdul Aziz is scheduled to hear the applications on Wednesday.
= == = == = == = == == = == = == = ==
M'sian court rejects application to free ethnic Indian activist
The plea to free M. Manoharan of the Hindu Rights Action Force was rejected on a technicality, said defence lawyer Karpal Singh. He said High Court judge Muhamad Ideres Muhamad Rapee ruled the application invalid because it was accompanied by an uncertified copy of the detention order.
ABOVE: & BELOW: After being thrown out, PKR Leader Gobalkrishnan took time & explain the the crowd what happened
The copy should have been notarized by a proper authority, according to the judge in the northern town of
The two were among five ethnic Indian leaders who were imprisoned last Thursday under the Internal Security Act for alleged sedition and threatening national security. The ISA allows for detention without trial for an initial period of two years that can be extended indefinitely. Mr Karpal said if the application for the release of Manoharan and Ganabatirau is accepted, the ruling could be applied to the remaining three. The five activists organized a rally on Nov. 25 in which some 20,000 ethnic Indians voiced the community's demand for equal rights. Police used tear gas and water cannons to quell the protest, and charged 31 other people with attempted murder. The charge was dropped on Monday. Indians, who account for 8 per cent and are at the bottom of the economic and social ladder, complain their temples have been demolished and they face disadvantages in education, job and business opportunities. The government dominated by Muslim Malays - who account for 60 per cent of
Hindraf lawyer Manoharan fails in habeas corpus application
IPOH (Dec 19, 2007): Lawyer M.Manoharan had his application for a writ of habeas corpus seeking his release from detention under the Internal Security Act (ISA) struck off by the High Court here today. Justice Datuk Muhamad Ideres Muhamad Rapee said the copy of the detention order that was attached to the application had not been certified by a Commissioner for Oaths. He said the application thus did not comply with provisions of the Rules of the High Court and therefore "the application is struck out". Counsel Krpal Singh told reporters later that he would submit a fresh application for Manoharan, 46, and another ISA detainee, V. Ganabathirau, 34, at the Kuala Lumpur High Court this afternoon. The two, together with three others, namely P.Uthayakumar, 46, R. Kengadharan, 40, and T. Vasanthakumar, 34, are accused to be behind an unlawful Hindu Righst Action Force (Hindraf) assembly held in the federal capital last month. They were detained last Thursday (Dec 13). The habeas corpus application was filed last Friday (Dec 14) and was fixed for mention before Judicial Commissioner Ridwan Ibrahim today. Karpal Singh said: "I was informed on Monday (Dec 17) that the case has been assigned for mention before Muhamad Ideres. I now want to know who directed the change of judge. "The judge (Muhamad Ideres) was informed that I would be late. Why did Muhamad Ideres decided not to wait for me to be present?" Karpal Singh was about 15 minutes late. The court sat for only five minutes from . It was packed with members and opposition party members as early with tight police security in the court compound.
== = == =
11 Seditious, Smut Blogs, Websites Blocked, Dewan Negara Told
Replying to Senator Datuk Armani Mahiruddin, he said it was not difficult to block websites and blogs than e-mails featuring advertisements and pornography. "So far there is no specific mechanism to monitor e-mails as there are millions of e-mails being sent daily," he said. Mohamed Ruddin also said the ministry has not done any study to gauge to what extent information technology has an impact on the moral of teenagers .
= == = == Coming next post soon on
MORE PICS – Hundreds of Opposition & NGOs Activists on streets again to Assert rights of Peacful Assembly